logo
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Services
  • Team
  • Blog
  • Articles
    • Audits and Objections
    • Bottom Line Article on Privilege
    • Communicating with LPC
    • Estate freezes
    • Going to Tax Court
    • Leaving Canada
    • Maintaining Minute Books
    • Objection Tips and Tricks
    • Privacy Policy
    • Real property registry
    • Shareholder loans
    • Voluntary Disclosures
    • Why Multiple Classes?
    • Audit process

Category Archives: Professional Corps

February 6, 2018 · Loukidelis

New frontier

Alex Klyguine, in “Income Splitting After the New Private Corporation Proposals: Salaries Paid to Family Members” 8:1 Canadian Tax Focus (February 2018), discusses Gabco Limited v MNR, 68 DTC 5210 (Ex. Ct.)), and suggests that “the boundaries of the reasonableness test may become the new frontier for income splitting in private corporations.” What is “reasonable”? Fair market value is not necessarily the relevant standard. In Gabco, the court wrote:

It is not a question of the Minister or this Court substituting its judgment for what is a reasonable amount to pay, but rather a case of the Minister or the Court coming to the conclusion that no reasonable business [person] would have contracted to pay such an amount having only the business consideration of the appellant in mind.

Posted in Professional Corps, TOSI |
November 30, 2015 · Loukidelis

Discretionary dividend shares

Readers of this blog will know that I am not a fan of discretionary dividend shares (shares issued for $1, or some other nominal amount, that are redeemable for that amount but entitled to unlimited dividends). I harbour these concerns despite that these types of shares appear to be the rule rather than the exception in medical professional corporations. Joan E. Jung and Cynthia M. McIntyre, “Current Issues,” 2013 Ontario Tax Conference, (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 2013), contains a good discussion of the CRA concerns regarding the shares. The CRA has questioned whether such shares, when they are issued for $1, have been issued for fair market value (has the corporation conferred a benefit where the shares are issued for the nominal amount?). The CRA has also raised the spectre of 69(1)(b), per R v Kieboom, 92 DTC 6382 (FCA), and the possible application of the GAAR.

The authors appear to believe that a freeze under section 51 or 86, coupled with a price adjustment clause (PAC) and followed by the issue of dividend shares, should address the 15(1) and 69(1)(b) concerns. I’m not so optimistic: if the CRA thinks the issue of dividend shares is abusive, will it respect the PAC?

Posted in Professional Corps |
April 2, 2015 · Loukidelis

Tax fairness for realtors

Bill 69, the Tax Fairness for Realtors Act, 2015, received first reading in the Ontario legislative assembly on February 26, 2015. The explanatory note accompanying the Bill reads as follows:

The Bill amends the Real Estate and Business Brokers Act, 2002 to permit a personal real estate corporation to be registered as a broker or salesperson. A personal real estate corporation must be incorporated as a professional corporation under the Business Corporations Act and be authorized only to trade in real estate.

In addition, the Bill amends the Real Estate and Business Brokers Act, 2002 to permit a brokerage to pay commission or other remuneration to a personal real estate corporation of an individual broker or salesperson that it employs.

Postscript: The Bill, it appears, was introduced by a Conservative MPP.

Posted in Professional Corps |
January 5, 2015 · Loukidelis

PCs for doctors: a long overdue change

The application and renewal process for certificates of status for the professional corporations (PCs) of doctors and dentists was rather labyrinthine. The College of Physicians and Surgeons recently announced that the process for doctors has been simplified. In an email it sent to subscribers to its corporate mailing list, the College summarized the changes as follows. Continue reading →

Posted in Professional Corps |
October 26, 2014 · Loukidelis

Inter-company Management Fees

A detailed services agreement was not enough by itself to justify the deduction of management fees paid by Opco to Holdco. The court wanted evidence of the services rendered, the service hours provided, the hourly rate and the identity of the person who provided the services. See Bessette c Agence du revenu du Québec, 2014 QCCQ 4329, summarized in Tax for the Owner-Manager 14:4 (October 2014).

Posted in Corporations, Professional Corps |
September 27, 2014 · Loukidelis

PC Income Splitting

Assume that Ms X, a lawyer in Ontario, wishes to incorporate a professional corporation (PC). Unlike her doctor and dentist clients, she can’t permit her husband to subscribe for shares in the capital of the PC because only members of the legal profession are permitted to own shares of a legal PC. Perhaps she can income split anyway, however, if she incorporates a corporation, her husband subscribes for some of its shares and then gifts the shares to Ms X. Ms X can then apply for a certificate of authorization for the PC. (It seems she will need to amend the articles of the corporation after her husband obtains and then gifts his shares but before she applies for the certificate because the Law Society will require the articles to include a clause prohibiting shareholders who are not lawyers.) Under ITA subsection 74.1(1), dividends paid on the gifted shares will be attributed to the husband.

The CRA, however, believes that the anti-avoidance rule in subsection 74.5(11) might apply so that attribution won’t occur. See TI 2014-0519661E5 (March 24, 2014) summarized in Robert Lee, “Subsection 74.5(11) and Professional Corporation Shares” (July 2014) 14:3 Tax for the Owner-Manager.

Posted in Professional Corps |

About this site

Click here for an important disclaimer about this site.

Archives

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Trust allocations gone awry
  • AAII integration anomaly
  • New shareholder register
  • GAAR to be applied only when benefit realized
  • Audit reversals
© Loukidelis Professional Corporation